Kim Strassel sifts thru the FBI’s garbage

In today’s WSJ…

Former FBI informant Alexander Smirnov, second from right, leaves a courthouse in Las Vegas, Feb. 20. Photo: Bizuayehu Tesfaye/Associated Press

There’s a lesson for informants (and politicians) everywhere in the Alexander Smirnov story: If you are going to lie to the Federal Bureau of Investigation, make sure it’s a lie the FBI wants to hear.

That’s not the story the media is telling about the arrest of Mr. Smirnov, the FBI “confidential human source” indicted last week for allegedly fabricating claims that Joe and Hunter Biden received bribes from a Ukrainian energy firm. The press instead is using the revelation to slather egg all over the faces of congressional Republicans who highlighted those claims as part of their investigation of the Biden family business. The better question: Does the FBI apply anything beyond politics to its disaster of a confidential source program?

It’s not as if Mr. Smirnov is alone. The FBI enabled the “dossier” hoax by swallowing a compilation of fabulist claims presented to it by “confidential human source” Christopher Steele. It was aware Mr. Steele was working for Hillary Clinton’s 2016 campaign, had evidence he was blabbing to the press, and had been presented with a pile of tabloid-like accusations, yet chose to forgo any vetting and instead present him to a court as a credible source. Mr. Steele’s nonsense—coming at a time FBI leadership fretted over a Donald Trump presidency—was nonsense the FBI wanted to hear.

Special counsel John Durham later filed charges against Igor Danchenko, one of Mr. Steele’s subsources, presenting powerful evidence that he lied to the FBI in 2017 interviews by fabricating sources and information. Yet a jury acquitted Mr. Danchenko after FBI agents testified that while they couldn’t verify his claims, never made him take a polygraph test, and feared he was lying, they nonetheless trusted him. Mr. Danchenko’s credibility—coming at a time when the FBI’s reputation risked further collapse—was a credibility the FBI found useful to back.

Mr. Smirnov seems unlikely to be as lucky. According to the indictment, in 2020 he told the FBI that Burisma executives had told him in 2015 and 2016 that they hired Hunter to “protect us, through his dad” and had paid Hunter and Joe $5 million apiece for that aid. When Republicans in 2023 heard about the FBI write-up of these claims, they demanded the bureau hand it over. The FBI initially balked, arguing their source was too valuable to risk exposing.

House Oversight Committee Republicans say the FBI told Congress their source had worked for the bureau since 2010, had been paid roughly $200,000 for information, and was deemed “highly credible.” Ranking Oversight Democrat Jamie Raskin acknowledged the FBI’s briefing about credibility. Republicans say Director Christopher Wray also confirmed the FBI used Mr. Smirnov’s information in investigations until June 2023 (when the bribery claims went public). The FBI affirmed Mr. Smirnov’s credibility so long as it was useful to do so.

It isn’t useful any longer. Republicans for months have hounded special counsel David Weiss, who is handling the Hunter Biden probe, to explain what he’s done since 2020 to verify or refute the Smirnov claims. Last week’s indictment, which he sought, is his answer. The FBI’s “highly credible” source is now presented as a brazen liar, a boaster, a profiteer who played a double game with the bureau, and a partisan who had it in for Joe Biden.

If this is true, it ought to be massive story that the FBI for 13 years relied on a man who prosecutors now worry has troubling and “extensive” ties to Russian intelligence. Instead, the media in its desire to embarrass Republicans is working to absolve the FBI, with the 

New York Times

explaining the bureau never did “think much” of the Smirnov claims and concluded in 2020 that they “did not merit continued investigation.” 

That’s it? The FBI is presented with an explosive bribery claim about a former vice president from a “credible source” who says it came directly from participants, dismisses said claim, and does nothing to re-evaluate its relationship with that source? (Mr. Smirnov hasn’t entered a plea, and his lawyers say he intends to “fight the power of the government.”)

This incompetence is having real-world consequences. The country is still living with the fallout from the Russia-collusion hoax, while Hunter’s lawyers have already filed court papers claiming Mr. Smirnov’s “rabbit hole of lies” “infected” the case against their client. Shall we add up the taxpayer cost of special counsel Robert Mueller’s investigation, Mr. Durham’s clean-up of it, the Justice Department’s manpower on the Smirnov case, and congressional and inspector-general investigations? That’s aside from the serious question of whether FBI sources are rightly beginning to worry that their worth depends solely on how politically useful the FBI views them on any given day.

The GOP’s Biden probe doesn’t sink or swim on the bribery claims, though given recent history Republicans would have been wise to treat the dramatic Smirnov accusations more carefully. Garbage in is garbage out. But it’s the FBI that ought to have to explain the steaming pile of trash.

— Kimberley Strassel

https://www.wsj.com/articles/sifting-fbi-garbage-alexander-smirnov-indictment-says-nothing-good-about-bureau-b4302f22?mod=hp_opin_pos_2#cxrecs_s

By Radiopatriot

A former talk radio host turned political activist, diving deep into the intricacies of political warfare and sharing insights on the shadow government and 5th Generation Psy-Ops. RadioPatriot's been diving into political intrigue, from FBI hearings to questioning staged events. Twitter.com/RadioPatriot * Telegram/Radiopatriot * Telegram/Andrea Shea King Gettr/radiopatriot * TRUTHsocial/Radiopatriot

2 comments

  1. As expeditious the Funny Bois of Insurrection have been moving forward with anything that represents investigating the O’Buydem crime family — taking years in an attempt to make much of that disappear including the Hunter laptop from hell, the best action to take would be for whichever congressional committee is running the investigation to continue to dog the Funny Bois for another 11 months, which at that time our President will likely have teams of investigators ready to start arresting the traitors.

    The guilty Funny Bois traitors, more than likely at or near the top of the pyramid, obviously must think they’ve completely pulled this off and their swamp pals will cover for them where needed like they have in the past … so it’s doubtful they’ve packed any bags or bought tickets to Brazil.

    Hopefully by that time at least some of the criminal Uni-party clowns would be replaced with MAGA patriots ready to get started on some of that rule of law action that needs to happen to the traitorous criminal clowns.

    If Wray has managed to pull off the acting role of the century I will feel pretty stupid when the dust clears. He’s played the part so well I almost hope he wasn’t acting. I keep seeing that Q post where he said, “Trust Wray (and Sessions and Grassley).

    (I’ve been wondering about that post – a lot – since Grassley voted with the RINOs on the last Ukraine $60 billion “aid” bill … )

    It’ll seem like forever but time will go by fast. Then GITMO is gonna get real busy.

    NCSWIC

  2. Just when you think a once highly respected organization of our government, FBI, could fall any further, along comes the CIA to prove us wrong and wake us up. Lordy it seems all the others are following suit.

Leave a comment